Click here to get this post in PDF
Businesses and marketers often make the mistake of relying only on research when they run a paid advertising campaign. While researching is a crucial part of the process, the work does not end there. The truth is that no amount of research will guarantee that every campaign will turn out successful — you need something a bit more concrete.
This is where A/B testing comes in. It is one of the most effective ways to improve your campaign’s performance and gain insights into what you can adjust for future efforts. In this post, we’ll walk you through everything a newcomer needs to know about A/B testing, along with useful best practices and common pitfalls to avoid.
What Is A/B Testing?
A/B testing is a marketing strategy where you test two versions of an asset against one another to see which one shows statistical improvement. In paid ads specifically, it refers to either testing two different ad formats, landing pages, call to actions, visual elements, audience targeting, or bidding strategies against each other.
For instance, a company could choose to test two different versions of a Facebook Carousel Ad, each featuring a different photo of the same product. They would do this to see which one generates more engagement or conversions. Another example could be testing two headlines for a Google Search Ad to identify which version generates a higher click-through rate (CTR).
Doing these types of tests provides you with valuable data you can use to guide your decisions such as where to allocate your ad budget. It also provides key insights for future campaigns allowing you to not repeat the same mistakes you have made in the past.
How Does A/B Testing Work?
The way A/B testing works is that it shows users two different versions of the same asset to identify which one performs better. The process starts with the marketer choosing a marketing goal, such as an increased conversion rate or an improved CTR.
Next, two versions of the asset are created. Variant A is the control and is usually the version already in use. Variant B is mostly identical to the control version except for a single element. This change could include a different image, headline, CTA or any other element.
To help ensure accurate results, the audience is randomly split into two groups. Each group is then shown one of the versions simultaneously and the test is underway. Thanks to the randomness involved, it ensures that external factors do not influence the results.
As the A/B test continues to run, the performance data of both variants are collected.
After enough time has passed — usually around two weeks, the data of both versions are examined to determine which variant performed better.
This is based on the metric goal the marketer chose at the beginning of the A/B test. Once the winner is selected, the campaign is optimized to only show that version. This is what A/B testing is all about — making small changes to see what results in increased campaign performance.
Why A/B Testing Is Crucial in Paid Advertising
A/B testing is crucial as it allows marketers to make data-driven decisions that can increase the effectiveness of their advertising campaigns. Instead of making adjustments based on guesswork, they can base their changes on performance data that shows what works and what does not.
This eliminates uncertainty and aids them in making adjustments that drive their marketing efforts forward. Successfully A/B testing campaigns can increase conversions, click-through rates and improve the return on investment (ROI). For expert guidance, consider partnering with a paid advertising agency to enhance your campaigns
In addition, A/B testing also helps to reduce risk. The thing is that when it comes to launching an ad campaign or making changes to an existing one, businesses always face the risk that it could result in failure. However, A/B testing decreases this risk as it allows for controlled experimentation on a small scale.
Testing changes before rolling them out to your entire audience enables marketers to make improvements that positively impact their campaigns. Over time, this consistent testing can help improve campaign performance and reveal insights on how to carry out future strategies, helping to enhance the effectiveness of current and future campaigns.
Best Practices for A/B Testing in Paid Advertising
A/B testing is one of the most effective ways of figuring out what works with your marketing campaigns and what does not. Thanks to the data gathered it allows you to better understand what your target audience is after and enables you to adjust your strategies based on these preferences.
While A/B testing doesn’t reveal why certain elements perform better, it does provide clear evidence that allows you to refine your marketing efforts. Here is a quick look at some best practices to ensure you get the most out of your A/B tests.
1. Set Clear Objectives
The first thing you will want to do is ensure you set clear objectives for the A/B test. Meaning, what do you want to happen? Do you want to see an increase in conversions or do you want your advert to have a lower cost per click (CPC)? Setting clear objectives allows you to more accurately determine how effective the A/B testing was at reaching these goals.
2. Only Test One Variable at a Time
While you can essentially change more than one element on your ad, this does make it more challenging to determine what change caused the difference in performance. Also, when you start experimenting with more than one variable, you enter the world of Multivariate testing, which is a whole different ball game compared to A/B testing. For that reason, it is better to stick to one element and ensure you get accurate results.
3. Large Enough Sample Size
You will want to make sure that you have a large enough sample size for your A/B test. Testing with a smaller sample size can open the door to random variables affecting your outcomes and leaving you with misleading results. On the other side, larger sample sizes, help to reduce the chance of random components jeopardizing your results, ensuring your findings are more reliable.
4. Prioritize Statistical Significance
Another best practice that you will want to ensure you focus on is that you prioritize statistical significance. This best practice also goes hand in hand with the previous tip we mentioned. Statistical significance indicates that the results obtained are directly due to the adjustments you made and not because of random chance. Ensuring that your findings are statistically significant, allows you to make informed decisions that drive your marketing campaigns forward.
5. Run The Test Long Enough
Another best practice you want to keep top of mind is that you run your A/B tests for a long enough period. Ending your test prematurely can lead to inaccurate conclusions, as you may not have gathered enough data yet to reach statistical significance. You will want the duration to be long enough to account for variations in user behaviour and to ensure that your findings reflect true performance differences.
4 Common Pitfalls to Avoid in A/B Testing
While A/B tests are a great way to improve campaign effectiveness, there are a few common missteps you will want to avoid. Here is a quick rundown of them:
1. Overanalyzing Data
Overanalyzing the data is one of the most common pitfalls that occur when marketers excessively look for patterns beyond what the data can realistically support. This often leads to confusion or misguided decision-making on their part.
The best way to avoid falling victim to this misstep is to stick to the metrics that are relevant to your goal. Don’t get caught up in analyzing the results that you start finding patterns that don’t exist.
2. Failing to Control for External Factors
Outside factors such as seasonality or changes in the market can dramatically affect results. Therefore, it is crucial that you actively account for these variables. For instance, if you were running a campaign during the Christmas holiday, the increased spending behaviour could indicate the advert is performing well.
However, in reality, this most likely has little relevance to the adjustments implemented and is probably directly related to the seasonal change. Recognizing and accounting for these external factors is vital to ensure your A/B test results are meaningful.
3. Not Considering User Experience
Another pitfall worth mentioning is that marketers often make changes that result in short-term positive gains but disregard the effect this will have on user experience. In the long run, this leaves them with a result that negatively impacts customer satisfaction.
Instead, they should aim to make adjustments that not only positively affect their metrics but also the user experience. Try to actively avoid making this mistake. While you might see good results initially, in the long run, it is a losing deal.
4. Assuming Results Will Remain the Same
Many newcomers often fall into the trap of thinking that their findings will remain the same forever. However, this is not the case. The truth is that consumer behaviour constantly changes, as do market conditions.
Making adjustments based on outdated findings can lead to ineffective strategies, wasted resources and missed opportunities. You will want to regularly revisit A/B test results to ensure your marketing efforts remain relevant.
Making The Most Out of Your A/B Test Findings
A/B tests are great at enhancing campaign performance and revealing key insights that can empower future strategies. With a few best practices, you can ensure that you make the most of your A/B test findings.
Setting clear objectives, testing one variable at a time and prioritizing statistical significance will help you obtain relevant results. On the other side, actively avoiding missteps such as overanalyzing data and failing to account for external factors ensures that your insights remain relevant and actionable.
Ultimately, A/B testing is more than just making changes to an ad campaign; it is about continuously looking for areas in which you can improve and learn from past mistakes. With marketers adopting a holistic approach, they can lay a solid foundation that leads to increased campaign performance, for current and future marketing efforts.
You may also like: How important are negative keywords for your ad campaign?
Image source: DepositPhotos.com
